'The Masked Singer' Group B Semifinals' Best Performances, Biggest Moments and Shocking Unmaskings

... Queer Eye star Bobby Berk!

Once again, the panel proves to be entirely incorrect!

"I can't believe it! Your voice is incredible!" Jenny marvels.

"Thank you guys for being out there in the world and entertaining people. More than ever we need amazing people like you who make us smile. No matter how stupid some of the things you say are, they make us smile!"
 

Nicole's First Impression: Chris Brown
Nicole's Final Guess: Tyler Hubbard

Ken's First Impression: Aaron Carter
Ken's Final Guess: Dan Levy

Jenny's First Impression: Brian Littrell
Jenny's Final Guess: Owen Wilson

Robin's First Impression: Howie Dorough
Robin's Final Guess: AJ McLean

Cheryl's Final Guess: Jim Parsons

Okay, one down and one to go. So, who's it gonna be?

After all the audience votes are cast, the second contestant going home is The Caterpillar. 

... Duck Dynasty star Willie Robertson!

Wow, none of the panelists were even close to correct!

"It was one of the hardest things I've ever done," Robertson shares, adding, ""Most of the people that you've named, I'm friends with!"

He closes out his Masked Singer journey with an unmasked rendition of "Fly" and it's a lot of fun.

Robin's First Impression: Larry the Cable Guy
Robin's Final Guess: Alan Jackson

Jenny's First Impression: Toby Keith
Jenny's Final Guess: Jason Aldean

Nicole's First Impression: Dierks Bentley
Nicole's Final Guess: Dog the Bounty Hunter

Ken's First Impression: Billy Ray Cyrus
Ken's Final Guess: Billy Ray Cyrus

Cheryl's Final Guess: George Foreman

All the votes have been cast! So who's getting the axe?

The Mallard is the first costumed contestant who will be getting revealed tonight!

It's hard to believe that two singers are going to have to go home tonight. It's kind of a bummer.

However, at least we're gonna get some answers!

So, it's time to vote. Who's going home?

We're gonna have to wait until after the commercial to find out.
 

Whoever The Queen of Hearts really is, she's an undeniable talent.

This week, she's tapping into that classic nostalgia feel with a gorgeous rendition of "She's Got You" by Patsy Cline.

Truly, her voice is next-level and the panel and the audience can tell just how much of a powerhouse she really is.

"You have a such a gift," Jenny says. "What a beautiful voice."

"This song represents that, if it don't work out with a man, you thank God -- because it means a better one's coming," Queen shares.

Bonus Clue:

The trophy for The Queen of Hearts is the Blockbuster Entertainment Award.

"I've got to say, when I won it, I felt like a real leading lady," The Queen of Hearts shares.

Panelists' Guesses:

Cheryl says it could be Kristen Chenowith.

Ken thinks Kelly Clarkson.

Nicole thinks it could be Sia.

The Queen of Hearts:

- Says, "I'm gonna lean into the one thing that hopefully sets me apart, and that's me heart."

- Says, "This next song reminds me of the best and worst time in my life."

- Says, "Worst because a dream was ending. One I never thought would. But best because there I was on the other side of it, stronger than I thought I ever could be."

For his performance this week, The Mallard plays up his English aristocracy look before a record scratch sound effect introduces the actual tune he'll be signing -- the decidedly non-aristocratic "Fly" by Sugar Ray.

"I'm so impressed with you," Nicole says. "You're so cool. I feel like we should all hang out on a lake or something."

While it's fun to hear him perform, the number itself feels a little underwhelming. It's hard to know how this song will play when it comes to grabbing votes at the end of the night.

Bonus Clue:

The Mallard's special accolade is a small poster that reads "Barbara Walters' 10 Most Fascinating People"

"Being known as fascinated has always been my true calling," The Mallard says.

Panelists' Guesses:

Nicole suggests Dog the Bounty Hunter

Ken says it might be Garth Brooks (???)

Cheryl says it could be George Forman.

Wow, Nick is 100 percent right when he says "this might be the craziest guess range ever."

The Mallard:

- Says, 'The fact that I keep going is insane, because I am 100 percent the under-duck."

- Says, "Mallards love to eat Banana Splits, and Caterpillars make good bait for fishing."

- Says his kids "always groan at my dad jokes."

- He reveals that he has "lots" of kids.

There's no going back from this now. Jenny has pushed the button and is locked in.

She says she think's it's an Oscar winner.

She thinks the country music clues lead to Brokeback Mountain.

She thinks the references to signing with his sister could be Maggie Gyllenhaal.

That's right! Jenny is inexplicably convinced that this is 100% Jake Gyllenhaal!

Robin doesn't seem convinced at all.

Amid the chants of "Take it off" we find out---

No. Obviously it's not Jake Gyllenhaal. It was never going to be Jake Gyllenhaal.

"Yo! I could have told you it wasn't Jake Gyllenhaal, ya'll!" Nicole declares.

This means the buzzer if "officially retired for the season" after Ken wrongly guessed The Pepper was Sara Bareilles last week.

Jenny is SURE she thinks she knows who it is, and calls for the Take It Off Buzzer.

She's so excited, and The Caterpillar is begging her not to.

Before we can see if she does -- it cuts to commercial!

The Caterpillar is certainly showing off his range this week, crooning the Garth Brooks hit "Friends In Low Places" like a pro.

The tone of The Caterpillar's voice is totally unlike anything he's shown us before, and it's clear how impressed (and confused) the panelists really are.

Sometimes more subdued songs aren't hits with the audience, but certainly not in this case.

"I'm stumped!" Jenny marvels.

"I was expecting a sort of nerdy sounding person," Cheryl admits.

Bonus Clue:

The Caterpillar's trophy is a "State Champion Bible Quiz First Place" plaque.

"This award was a crowning achievement in my life," The Caterpillar says. "But nothing comes close to when I received that VMA Award."

That's how you drop a twist in a big way.

Panelists' Guesses:

Nicole thinks it might be Tyler Hubbard of Florida Georgia Line.

Cheryl suggests Jim Parsons.

Jenny guesses Luke or Owen Wilson.

The Caterpillar:

- Says, "I've never done anythign like this before, but I'm doin what I've done my whole life -- fake it until you make it."

- Says, "My mission for this next performance is to show some range."

- Says he'll be performing an "old country song" that he used to sing with his sister.

- Says it takes him back to where he grew up.

- Says, "When you fake it until you make it, and then you finally make it, it feels pretty damn good!"

Tonight, Banana Split is throwing us a real curveball. The number begins with The Banana at the piano, but as Ice Cream belts out the opening lines to Lady Gaga's "Poker Face," Banana walks over and starts banging away at the drums like a pro.

The Ice Cream is showing off a lot of her dance moves as she's joined by cupcake-adorned backup dancers, and she  owns the stage like a seasoned pop star icon.

There's even an orchestral accompaniment that The Banana conducts -- showing a wild range of different musical aptitudes.

Needless to say, the song is a big hit.

"Can I just say, what a way to open the show!" Jenny says. "It was absolutely incredible!"

Bonus Clue:

Tonight's bonus clue theme is "Bring your trophy to work day," where the contestants show off a accolade they've earned that they are proud of.

For Banana Split, their trophy is... a whole bunch of trophies! Including one that says "Favorite Hottie."

"Collectively, we have won quite a few awards," The Banana explains. "But that one you pointed out, I'm particularly proud of."

"Well, it's pretty obvious who the hottie is," he adds with a laugh, while gesturing toward Ice Cream. "It ain't me."

The Banana asks Ice Cream how she won that award, and Ice Cream says, "I don't remember, and that could be the real problem."

Panelists' Guesses:

Jenny suggests it could be Ed Sheeran and Jessie J.

Robin thinks it could be Ryan Tedder and Leona Lewis.

Nicole guesses John Krasinski and Emily Blunt (although she cannot for the life of her say "Krasinski.")
 

Banana Split:

- Ice Cream says, "I think our strength is that we're theatrical. We put on a show"

- Banana says, "We're making 90-second movies."

- Banana holds his fingers up in double Peace signs.

- Ice Cream says, "We want to throw them off with this song, so we're channeling our inner pop stars."

- Banana says, "It's funny because one of us dreaming about being a pop star, but it didn't really pan out."

This Group B semifinals wouldn't be complete without some additional star power on the panel.

This week, hidden at first behind a feather masquerade mask, is actress Cheryl Hines!

This marks her second time as a guest panelist on the show, following her appearance during the Group B finals in Season 4 last November. Almost exactly one year ago to the day.

Wow, this season is going so fast!

Tonight, we going to be seeing some of the best vocal talents in this competition duke it out, and I personally can't wait.

We've also got another double elimination, meaning once again we're cutting the competition down quite a bit as we barrel toward the season finale.

So who will be joining The Skunk and The Bull? I can't wait to find out!