By Antoinette Bueno
7:46 AM PDT, May 7, 2013
More than a few A-list ladies were willing to experiment with their eye makeup at Monday night's Costume Institute Gala at the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York City, but these beauty looks you just have to see to believe!
First up is January Jones, who took her black eyeliner to a whole new level with this alien-chic look.
1 / 5
Rad or Bad?
Getty Images
More than a few A-list ladies were willing to experiment with their eye makeup at Monday night's Costume Institute Gala at the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York City, but these beauty looks you just have to see to believe!
First up is January Jones, who took her black eyeliner to a whole new level with this alien-chic look.
First up is January Jones, who took her black eyeliner to a whole new level with this alien-chic look.
Ginnifer Goodwin
Getty Images
Is Ginnifer Goodwin's dramatically dark eyeshadow great from afar ... or downright bizarre?
Elle Fanning
Getty Images
At only 15 years old, Elle Fanning made a splash at the Met Gala, giving off some serious Black Swan-style glamour.
Jessica Pare
Getty Images
Did she and Ginnifer get ready together?
Lily Collins
Getty Images
Lily Collins looked almost unrecognizable next to boyfriend Jamie Campbell Bower, playing up her famously thick brows with this unconventional use of black liner.