By Antoinette Bueno
3:00 AM PDT, May 5, 2012
Is January Jones' Mary Katrantzou dress beautifully bold, or does it make her look old?
1 / 11
Slide 1 of 11
January Jones

Getty Images
Is January Jones' Mary Katrantzou dress beautifully bold, or does it make her look old?
Carrie Underwood

Getty Images
Are you feeling Carrie Underwood's country style, or do you find it vile?
Elizabeth Hurley

Getty Images
Does Elizabeth Hurley still got it, or should she tone it down a bit?
Jennifer Lopez

Getty Images
Are you feeling the snake on her neck, or is this look a total wreck?
Kate Hudson

Getty Images
Is Kate Hudson's purple sequin number totally stunning, or should her stylist take off running?
Chloe Moretz

Getty Images
Is Chloe Moretz's floral Dolce & Gabbana dress all the rage, or a little old for her age?
Lea Michele

Getty Images
Does Lea Michele look white-hot in a mini, or does it make her look a little too skinny?
Heather Morris

Getty Images
Kooky and rad, or just really really bad?
Eva Mendes

Getty Images
Is Eva Mendes' plaid dress beautifully ladylike, or should it take a hike?
Scarlett Johansson

Getty Images
Are you loving Scarlett Johansson in mixed prints, or can she take a few fashion hints?
Tops & Flops: The Week in Fashion

Getty Images
The week in fashion featured some highs and serious lows, but which stars stood out, and which ones need new clothes? You decide!