Tops & Flops: The Week in Fashion

Is this dress making you think, "Where has Katherine Heigl been?!", or is it a major fashion sin?

Is Stacy Keibler's dress super glam, or do you wish she would show more of her envious gams?

Would you say Salma Hayek is best dressed, or this dress waaay too tight in the chest?

Does Michelle Pfeiffer put women half her age to shame, or is this black dress a little too tame?

Does Jennifer Aniston look better than ever in this low-cut number, or is this sparkly creation a fashion blunder?

Is Jayma Mays beautiful in blue, or should she try something new?

Does Demi Moore look hot in red, or does this dress fill you with dread?

Do you prefer Olivia Wilde in black, or is this dress just plain whack?

Is Miranda Kerr's pink gown a total hit, or are you not loving that thigh-high slit?

Is Emma Roberts' sweet '60s dress super cute, or should it get the boot?

The week in fashion featured an Elle event for women where the stars shined, but others' styles were so heinous they should be fined! Which celebs dressed to impress, and which ones just looked like a mess? You decide!